Painting vs staining difference

If you want to know about the main differences between painting and staining then this detailed guide will help you to gain complete information regarding this topic.

Newbies should stick to the end of this post in order to know the complete difference and similarities between these two materials.

painting and staining difference

Are you looking to refinish the wooden surfaces of your house? Then you need to decide what is preferable. Is it paint or stain? This article will help you to decide.

I will start with the similarities between painting and staining. Then I will discuss the differences between the two.

Painting and staining are two terms that are almost in the same context.

They both will provide you with the same finishing layer for your walls and doors. However, both have their own differences.

There are many reasons why homeowners prefer the beauty of wood to its synthetic counterpart. Wood has its own charm that speaks of elegance and warmth.

However, wood needs to be protected and preserved since it is sensitive to moisture and can easily get damaged. There are two ways to do this: paint or stain.

Painting vs staining difference

Staining wood is budget-friendly

There is no doubt that staining a wooden surface is cheaper than painting it. Staining can save you up to 70% of the budget unless you are painting a larger area.

If you want to keep the cost to a minimum, it is advisable to stain and not paint your wooden surface.

Not only is it cheaper, but the result is also better. But no one wants the look of stained wood.

Most people want a painted surface. There are two ways to do it, one is to paint over the stain and the other is to sand it off.

Staining gives a natural look

Some people prefer the natural look of wood and stain the wood in the same color as the surrounding areas (like the trim, cabinets, or flooring).

Others choose to change the color of the wood entirely and paint it.

Staining is a way to gradually change the color of the wood, while painting is more of a drastic change.

Staining is also cheaper than painting since it requires a smaller amount of money and time.

However, staining also needs to be reapplied more often than painting. So ultimately, it is up to you to choose what you like.

When it comes to staining wood, there are several different approaches you can take.

Wood stain is semi-solid as it only partially fills the surface pores of the wood, exposing the natural grain and giving off a more rustic look.

Paint offers a much different version of this look as it fully fills each surface pore and dries to an opaque finish while covering up any cracks or distinct grain patterns.

The solid color paint offers something in between by still filling many surface pores but leaving some empty spaces, although the space tends not to be noticeable unless viewed up close.

Paint has variety

Paint may come in a wide variance of colors but it should be chosen based on the type of room it is going to be used.

Dark paint might look nice in an entryway or living room, but would probably not be right for a kid’s bedroom.

Paint in this area of your house should reflect your child’s personality and offer some inspiration to his behavior and mannerisms.

The color you choose will most likely have a psychological effect if you’ve ever been in a brightly colored room versus one that was slightly darker or grey.

You’ll notice the difference almost immediately when you walk into the home – people feel confident, there are fewer arguments, and everyone behaves a little better!

Staining is easier than painting

Staining is the process of coloring the existing color of a hardwood floor. It is a lot easier to apply than paint.

Because of the lack of differences in colors between the existing hardwood floors and the color of the stain.

Also, staining is not dependent on the amount of moisture in the air or the surface on which you are staining.

Both of which can make painting difficult. Finally, staining doesn’t require a trained eye for mixing colors to get the desired shade.

Preparing your deck is easy, regardless of whether you’re going to paint or stain. Just sweep away any debris and scrub the deck down with a deck cleaner.

Meanwhile, remove any damaged boards and lightly sand any ridges that remain.

painting and staining difference

After that, simply brush on a coat of stain (or roll it on if you’re using Behr Waterproofing Stain & Sealer available for purchase at The Home Depot.)

This two-in-one product does all the work for you: no additional topcoat is needed!

Which last’s longer: Painting vs Staining

Both painting and staining are very durable and have been used on exterior wood surfaces for more than a century.

If properly applied, these coverings are extremely resistant to weathering and hold up very well.

If we compare painting and staining, staining usually lasts longer than painting.

The reason is, that when you paint the surface, new paint can peel off eventually which exposes the old surface.

When you stain the surface, the stain penetrates into the wood and the wood fibers lock the stain into the wood. Staining can last 10 years or longer. Painting can last six years or longer.

As long as they are maintained properly, they both should last a long time.

If you are painting, you should use high-quality paint that can last for at least a year without peeling, cracking, or fading.

The same is true for staining, although you have to be careful with the staining. If you are using a gloss finish, then you will have to reapply it more often than a satin finish.

Staining is easier to maintain

Staining is easier to maintain than paint. Staining is a lot easier to maintain. For instance, we have a deck in our backyard, and it is stained.

It has not been painted in seven years, and the deck is still in excellent condition.

Painting is much more laborious and time-consuming than staining. You need to apply several layers of paint to get the color and coverage you want.

Painting is also a lot more expensive than staining. Staining is an old method of protecting wood.

It is the process of coloring or coloring the wood or any other surfaces with a pigment. It is a process of making the surface look like it is actually stained.

A simple stain is just a thin coating of color that protects and beautifies the wood.

Still, most people prefer to paint over staining. Most of the time teenagers are hired to stain the wood. The cost of painting is much more than staining.

The process of staining is quite flexible. The process of staining lasts longer than painting.

The wood is not sacrificed in any way while staining. Staining is a very good way to protect the wood.

A stained surface is easier to paint

A stained deck can be easily turned into a painted deck.

To do this, you need to first dull the old paint finish by sanding it down with sandpaper and then eliminating it with something like a de-glosser.

You also need to prime your deck as this will get rid of any old stains or mildewy smells that might build up over time.

Only once your prepping work is done should you proceed to tint your deck’s wood layer with stains of the color of your choice!

If you have a deck with paint already but want to change the color, one way of doing so is by re-staining or topping it.

Stain can be easily painted over and needs only de-glosser and sandpaper and then a coat of primer followed by the new color finish.

Though it may get difficult sometimes as some types of artwork may come off when rubbing the paint too vigorously.

Pros of painting in decorating home

Paint is much thicker than stain and usually only needs one or two thin coats to cover a surface.

Sometimes, however, stains are so powerful that you need a lot more of them just to make sure you get the right effect.

Paint normally comes in more color options as well, though stains do work on bigger surfaces due to their powerful nature.

Paints also tend to be easier and more uniform in nature, whereas sometimes stains can be deceiving and can look streaky if they haven’t been spread out evenly at first.

It’s also very easy to paint over buffed surfaces, whereas staining over previously painted surfaces can be tricky because of the varying sheens between paint and stain.

Paint is easy to apply, it’s very affordable, comes in thousands of different colors, and gives a fresh new look to your home.

Pros of staining in decorating home

Stains are less expensive than paint. It is easy to apply, and you can remove chipping and fading easier.

You won’t need to push paint very hard into the corners of your room if you use stain, as it settles into corners more naturally and flows better along the wood grain.

Stains give a more rugged feel – perfect for a rustic style that hides imperfections rather than seeming out of place.

Paint is liable to peel, chip, or crack whereas stains are more resistant to these problems.

Is paint better than stain?

Paint and stain both have their own benefits and are better suited for different types of projects.

Paint is better for covering up imperfections in the wood and providing a consistent, opaque color.

It also provides better protection against water and UV damage. However, it can be more difficult to apply and can take longer to dry.

Stain, on the other hand, is better for highlighting the natural grain of the wood and can be applied more quickly.

It also tends to be more transparent, so it’s better for showing off the natural color and texture of the wood.

However, it may not provide as much protection against the elements and can be less durable.

So it depends on the look you want to achieve, the condition of the wood, and the level of protection you need.

What is the difference between staining and painting a deck?

Staining and painting a deck are two different ways to finish and protect the wood. The main difference between the two is in the look and level of protection they provide:

  • Staining a deck involves applying a transparent or semi-transparent color to the wood. This allows the natural grain and texture of the wood to show through, while also providing some protection against water and UV damage. Stains come in a wide range of colors, from light to dark, and can be oil- or water-based.
  • Painting a deck involves applying a solid, opaque color to the wood. This completely covers the natural grain and texture of the wood and provides a more consistent, uniform look. Paint also provides better protection against water and UV damage than stains, but it can be more difficult to apply and takes longer to dry.

In summary, staining a deck preserves and enhances the natural look of wood while adding some protection.

Whereas painting a deck can provide greater protection and change the look but will conceal the natural wood grain and texture.

What’s the difference between paint and solid stain?

Paint and solid stain are both used to finish and protect the wood, but they are different in a few key ways:

  • Paint is a liquid coating that is applied to the wood and dries to form a solid, opaque film. It completely covers the natural grain and texture of the wood, creating a consistent, uniform look. Paint is available in a wide range of colors and finishes, from flat to a high gloss. It provides good protection against water and UV damage.
  • Solid stain is a type of paint-stain hybrid, it is thicker and more heavily pigmented than traditional stains but not as thick as paint. It is also applied to the wood and dries to form a solid film. Unlike paint, the solid stain still allows some of the natural grain and texture of the wood to show through, but it does conceal it more than a traditional transparent or semi-transparent stain. Solid stain is also available in a wide range of colors, but it typically provides less protection against water and UV damage than paint.

In summary, paint creates a solid, opaque finish that covers the natural wood grain and texture.

While the solid stain is thicker and more pigmented than traditional stains and still allows some of the natural wood grain and texture to show through.

Can I use paint instead of stain?

Yes, you can use paint instead of stain on a deck, but it will affect the final look of the deck and the level of protection it provides.

Paint is a thicker coating than stain and it will completely cover the natural grain and texture of the wood, creating a consistent, uniform look.

It also provides better protection against water and UV damage than stains. However, it is more difficult to apply and takes longer to dry.

When using paint on a deck, it’s important to use paint that is specifically formulated for outdoor use and can withstand the elements.

Deck paint is typically more durable and resistant to peeling, chipping, and fading, compared to regular paint.

If you want to preserve the natural look of the wood and show off the grain and texture, the stain is probably a better choice.

However, if you want to completely change the color and appearance of the wood, or if you want to cover up any imperfections, the paint may be the better option.

FAQ’s of Painting vs staining difference

Staining is better than painting furniture. Staining is popular because it has the look of antique, and the application gets easier with practice. It is important to choose the right kind of stain. Oil and enamel stains are better. Paint is an appropriate choice when you want to change the color of the furniture, but it is not a good choice if you want to protect furniture from the sun or if you want to cover stains or scratches. If you are looking to make your furniture look better, then staining is the right choice. When staining, remember that you should always start with a clean piece of furniture. If you are not able to apply the stain evenly, then you can use a sandpaper. If you want to make your furniture look antique, then you should use a stain that can develop a patina over time. Such stains will help your furniture look aged, like a piece of antique furniture.

Yes, it is possible to paint over stain without sanding – but only if the stain is completely dry. If the stain is still moist, then there is a chance that the paint underneath might peel or bubble because of moisture getting trapped underneath the stain. The best way to check the dryness of stain is to check its consistency. If the stain is still sticky, then it is better to wait for a couple days before applying paint over it. If the stain is dry, then you can paint over it with primer or paint after sanding the surface to give it a smooth finish.

It is ok to paint over stained wood. If the stain is oil-based, then you have to sand off the old coating to expose the wood surface. You can use a wood conditioner as a primer. Ask the store clerk for which primer to use if you don’t know what kind of wood you have. After priming, use an oil-based paint over it. If the stain is water-based, then it is ok to paint over it only if the stain is still new and has not fully dried. If it is already dry and hard, then you will have to remove it first.

Sure, you can stain over paint, but you might want to make sure it’s compatible. Some paints may have chemicals in them that might inhibit the staining. Always test out your paints before attempting to stain. A good thing to do is to clean the wood, let it dry and then apply a stain-blocking sealer. This will seal the wood and help to prevent the stain from bleeding through. Another thing to remember is that it’s best to stain before you paint the surface. That way, you avoid the “tire-tracks” that are sometimes left by the paint brush.

Conclusion of Painting vs Staining

If you are new to woodworking and thinking of woodworking as a hobby or for business then this guide on painting vs staining is for you.

And you need to know about the basics of wood. Wood comes in many varieties and in many forms.

This guide has everything which you need to know before painting the wooden decks.

Or staining them for decoration purposes so stick to this guide whenever you are painting or staining your decks.

And if you still find any confusion in your mind then do let us know we will clear it out. Post your queries in the comments section and I will make sure you get entertained properly.

Matthew Edward

Matthew Edward is a professional painter who loves to paint and wants to share useful tips and tricks which he had learned in many years of experience in painting. He also used many products that can be used for painting he has tried and tested each and every product to give an unbias opinion about it in his review. This blog is very useful for those newbies who want to learn painting without making mistakes.

Leave a Comment